Book Review: Old Man’s War

My rating: 3 out of 5 stars

I will admit, that I was hesitant to listen to this audiobook. After listening to Redshirts, which I reviewed earlier this month, I was worried that this book would be bogged down with “he said, she said” dialogue much like Redshirts was. While there was a lot of “said” used in this book, there were at least other descriptors used as well, so that alone made the book more enjoyable.

The narrator, William Dugris, was a bit boring at times. His voice often had a flat, almost monotone quality to it, which at times made listening a chore, because my mind would wander away from the story. Overall, it wasn’t too bad to listen to, I just had to make sure to really pay attention. He did do a pretty decent job of giving each character their own unique voice.

I found the concept of the book interesting. The idea to recruit old people to a war effort, seems very unorthodox, even with the promise of anti-aging, so I was definitely curious to see how it would work out.

I felt like things were explained well enough. It didn’t feel bogged down by scientific jargon, but some explanations weren’t perfect – like the discussion about how the “beanstalk” didn’t follow the laws of physics. I get that things like that need to be explained or else readers will complain that it was missing valuable information, but then at times those descriptions feels like they go too deep.

It was nice to have a book where the main characters are older. So many books have characters from their teens to thirties, with the only older people being grandparents or elders, and they get small roles. Of course this changed as the book progress, what with the anti-aging process happening, but it was entertaining while it lasted. And yes, I understand that, in a way, those characters are still 70+ mentally, but it certainly changed things to have them also younger again.

Things got a little weird after the “anti-aging process”.

My interest started to wane a bit about the half way point when the characters were going through all their training. I don’t know if it’s because my interest in the story had lessened or if the narrators voice was just making me not care, but I definitely had to keep reminding myself to pay attention and listen to it or else I might miss everything.

There was a decent amount of action in this book, especially in the last quarter of it. I found a few of the characters to be great additions to John, but overall, I didn’t find that any of them stood out. I get that it was technically Johns story and thus the focus was on him, but I would have liked to see a bit more from the other characters – though maybe I will if I continue with the series. I also wish we could have seen more alien species, as there were only a few mentioned and most of those were just minor “oh look there’s a __” and that was it.

I may eventually continue on with this series, but I am in no major rush to. I am glad that I finally got around to this book.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Book Review: Old Man’s War

  1. I loved the first installment in the series. But I also read it, so the “he said, she said’ part may not have been as obvious. The series gets a bit more intriguing as you go and I hope you’ll give them a chance.

  2. I read my first Scalzi book a few months ago (The Collapsing Empire) so I was curious about his other books. Nice to see a review of this. I’m kind of ambivalent about this series, and after reading your review I might try one of his other ones instead. I’m not sure this one would grab me that much.

    Thanks for the review!

    • It might be one you enjoy, but if you want to skip it, then that’s fine. I think I’m going to give one of his other series a try, but if they don’t grab me then I might have to pass on future Scalzi reading.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s